Middle Cay | North Eleuthera

Middle Cay is a two-acre island which has two villas that offer five-star amenities in a secluded location. Conveniently, there are two docks on the island. In addition, one has an automatic boat lift and a 22’ boat with captain. A beautiful walkway winds around the entire island. A working lighthouse adds a touch of nautical charm. The surrounding islands are known for their pink sand beaches, coral reefs, and shipwrecks. Relax in the heated pool or visit neighboring Harbour Island. It offers jet skis, boat, bicycles, and golf cart rentals, as well as several restaurants. Inquire here.


7 guest rooms | 16 guests

Fishing gear, canoe, standup paddle board, kayaks

Large open living area and patio space

Air-conditioning and Wi-Fi

22′ boat with Captain



Boat and golf cart rental available

Breathtaking views